What Really Drives the cycle?

Large loss events are often treated as the turning points of insurance and reinsurance cycles. But what if one of the most powerful forces shaping those cycles sits outside the industry altogether – and is beyond its control?

THAT IS SOMETHING WE HAVE BEEN CONSIDERING AT HOLBORN.

For years now, we have been exploring the theory that global monetary policy – through its influence on inflation, interest rates, and ultimately the cost and availability of capital – may have considerably more influence on the direction and duration of underwriting cycles than is generally recognized.

The logic is simple. Monetary policy helps shape inflationary and deflationary environments, which in turn influence the cost of capital and its availability.

In the world of global capital markets, the idea of excess liquidity as a predominate factor in determining asset prices is not new; however, our research suggests that re/insurance is not immune.

When capital is inexpensive and plentiful, more capacity can enter the insurance and reinsurance markets, increase competition, and put downward pressure on pricing – even in years with significant losses. When capital becomes more expensive or scarce, capacity becomes more disciplined and pricing pressure can move in the opposite direction – even when industry losses are low. 

Major losses still matter, but rather than necessarily being the fundamental cause of a market turn, they may sometimes be significantly muted by global liquidity conditions or act as an accelerant or catalyst within a cycle whose underlying conditions have already been created by the wider capital environment.

Once you accept that hypothesis, it is also interesting to consider what it might mean for re/insurers’ approach to pricing, capital allocation, and cycle management. For instance, loose monetary policy may boost soft market conditions, as noted above; however, all else equal, it is also inflationary, which can be toxic for the re/insurance industry on both sides of the balance sheet, over time.

WHAT BOND MARKETS SHOW

As we sit here (October 2026), government bond yields are responding with multi-year highs – despite the US Treasury Department recently signaling a strong willingness to intervene. Looking ahead, the US Congressional Budget Office projects a federal deficit of $1.9 trillion in 2026, with debt held by the public equivalent to 101% of Gross Domestic Product. Net federal interest costs alone are projected at over $1 trillion this year.

The significance is not simply the size of these numbers, it is the relationship between debt, interest rates, and the need to refinance existing borrowing. Higher yields increase the cost of servicing debt. Persistent deficits require further borrowing. Increasing supply means investors must be willing to absorb greater quantities of government securities.

But foreign demand is presently falling for US Treasuries; as such, if the Federal Reserve increasingly needs to be “buyer of last resort,” the money printing required to fund those purchases is inflationary. This also exacerbates the cycle, as the US government would be borrowing from itself (increasing the debt load) in order to merely satisfy its own debt servicing obligations.

None of this tells us precisely where interest rates or inflation will go next. But it illustrates the wider point: The price and availability of capital do not exist independently of monetary and fiscal conditions. And neither, we would argue, do the impacts on the reinsurance cycle.

COST OF MONEY, PRICE OF RISK

Reinsurance is itself a form of capital. Insurers use it to manage volatility and protect their balance sheets; re/insurers and alternative capital providers deploy capital where they believe the return is adequate compensation for the risks assumed. Clearly, investors have a choice as to where they allocate capital.

When interest rates are low and liquidity plentiful, investors may be more willing to allocate capital to insurance and reinsurance risk in a search for additional points of margin. Low interest rates have often been cited as one factor behind the growth of alternative capital in catastrophe reinsurance.

Additional capacity increases competition and puts downward pressure on re/insurance pricing. Again, this may explain why major catastrophe losses do not always produce the degree of market hardening that might be expected – i.e., if the wider capital environment remains attractive to investors, lost capacity can be replenished surprisingly quickly, muting both the magnitude and duration of market hardening.

The opposite can also apply, as we saw most recently in 2022 leading up to January 1, 2023, reinsurance renewals: When risk-free yields rise, investors have more alternatives and the return required for assuming insurance risk increases. Bondholders also lose money when yields rise, as higher interest rates push down the price of their investments. Raising new capital becomes more difficult; existing funds become more selective about where they deploy capacity.

The catastrophe may be the event we see, but the capital environment may help determine what happens next.

This creates a well-documented tension: Higher interest rates improve insurers’ investment yields but can also decrease the value of their bond holdings, increase the cost of equity, and the return hurdle required to attract new money. Longer term, given US deficit spending, higher yields can also cause price inflation – to the extent it increases the need for new government borrowing to pay the interest, funded by the Federal Reserve. Ultimately, all of it changes the price of risk.

This is why the conventional narrative around underwriting cycles deserves examination. A hurricane, earthquake, or other major loss is highly visible and its effect immediate. Monetary conditions work differently. Their influence accumulates through inflation, investment returns, the cost of capital, and investor behavior.

INFLATION CUTS BOTH WAYS

There is a further complication for insurers and reinsurers: Inflation can affect both sides of the balance sheet. Abundant liquidity may lower re/insurance costs and contribute to increased available capacity, but it can also lead to competitive pressure and adverse loss trends due to inflation. The effect can be particularly significant in long-tail business, or when the distortion from excess global liquidity persists over many years – i.e., allowing the pressure from inflation to silently compound.

By the time higher loss costs become fully apparent through reported claims or reserve development, the business generating those losses may have been written years earlier. An environment that contributed to softer pricing can also help create conditions in which yesterday’s pricing assumptions are inadequate.

BEYOND THE LOSS EVENT

None of this suggests that catastrophe losses, underwriting discipline, reserve development, or changes in exposure cease to matter. They clearly do. Research into catastrophe reinsurance pricing has demonstrated that major losses can constrain the supply of reinsurance capital and increase prices, just as years with low or moderate loss activity have the opposite effect.

Our hypothesis is that these factors should also be viewed within a broader capital cycle: Monetary policy influences financial conditions and inflation; these, in turn, influence the cost of capital; capital availability affects competition and pricing. Thus, understanding monetary conditions offers a valuable context for understanding the underwriting cycle itself.

That matters for insurers – and their brokers. A broker’s role should extend well beyond what happened at the last renewal or predict whether rates will rise or fall. It should include helping clients understand the forces shaping the behavior of capital and what those forces may mean for future capacity, pricing, and program structure.

CONCLUSION

At Holborn, we believe that understanding market dynamics means looking beyond the immediate market and asking why conditions are changing. For clients, that means thinking about reinsurance strategy through the cycle – not simply renewal by renewal.

No one can reliably predict the next catastrophe. Predicting the next move in monetary policy can be equally hazardous. But, we can observe the forces shaping the cost and availability of capital – and consider what they may mean for reinsurance capacity, pricing, and structure. And if our hypothesis is right, the underwriting cycle may begin moving long before the insurance market realizes it has turned.

Risk that is understood, managed, and clearly communicated in a way that is consumable to everyone in your organization encourages a strong risk culture. Governance, training strategies, metrics & controls, and capital allocation are techniques to ensure day-to-today adherence to your ERM program and corporate strategy. Leveraging Holborn’s comprehensive tool suite, we help tailor an ERM framework that supports managing your risks. 

One of the key objectives of an insurer’s operating strategy is to maintain an acceptable target financial strength rating. Holborn has extensive experience in helping clients balance the sometimes-conflicting objectives of growth, profitability, portfolio optimization, capital adequacy, and multiple return metrics. Our robust financial analytics enable our clients to assess multiple key performance measures and analyze how various strategic decisions could be expected to impact the company’s financials and underlying qualitative and quantitative rating factors. 

By their very nature, catastrophic property losses can wreak havoc on businesses and personal property, as well as the balance sheet. Media coverage of the devastation from a hurricane or tornado often makes these events seem “unexpected.” Even though recorded weather history is relatively limited (on a geologic scale), it’s clear that outliers, storms of extraordinary magnitude, have occurred before and will again. 

It shouldn’t be a surprise that some of the largest insured events we see are not property, but liability-driven. Losses stemming from workers’ compensation, mass tort, clash, runaway defense costs, product liability, and punitive damage judgments can quickly add up to amounts greater than most weather or fire damages. Holborn monitors the litigious US landscape, tracking the latest judicial rulings and regional and local hotspots.

Contract wordings are continuously evolving to stay on top of emerging risks such as cyber, intellectual property, and labor laws. Working together, we ensure that the proper coverage and limits are maintained.  

Holborn’s Reinsurance Security Committee (a select group of our senior managers across multiple disciplines) meets regularly to review the financial condition of each reinsurer. Each entity is closely monitored for financial and operational performance through meetings with management, rating agency activity and news releases. Our monthly newsletters keep clients informed of any noteworthy changes. 

Holborn can provide clients with access to RiskRater®, a proprietary reinsurance pricing engine designed (but not limited) to manage portfolios of mutual insurers. RiskRater® employs a systematic approach to pricing that is consistent across client companies. Smaller companies with sparse rating histories are rated with the support of defined cohorts and compared with industry information to enable a more informed view of risk. Developed to be nimble and flexible without proprietary software installations, RiskRater® requires only a connection to a centralized database, where all data (present and historical) is stored and archived, allowing access to detailed information for year over year pricing. 

Our Vision

Our way includes giving the client peace of mind of knowing they can “shake the same hand” again and again over time, and that our team is uniquely positioned to represent their interests in the marketplace, given our in-depth knowledge of their operations, business plans and issues, nuances, history, and the way they like to receive service from us and from their reinsurers. This is how we define our “client intimacy strategy.”

Our Mission

The mission of Holborn Corporation is to provide efficient tailored risk assessment and reinsurance solutions to US insurance organizations, using markets of appropriate quality. Services include risk analytics, contract and claims management, and the maintenance of trading relationships with high-quality reinsurance markets throughout the world.